From Watchdog to Lapdog? Journalists Call Press Council’s Support to Kashmir Media Restrictions ‘Deplorable’


The statement quoted from Council chairman, Justice Chandramauli Kumar Prasad’s own speech from 2018, where he advocated for media freedom.

Journalists Call Press Council's Support to Kashmir Media Restrictions 'Deplorable'

The statement urges the Press Council to intervene in favour of Bhasin’s petition that demands an end to ban on communication in J&K. Photo: Reuters

The Wire Staff

The Wire Staff 25 August 2019

In a written statement, a group of journalists and media organisations have expressed “grave concern” at the Press Council of India’s (PCI) move to intervene in the petition filed by Kashmir Times executive editor Anuradha Bhasin in the Supreme Court.

The PCI’s intervention “does not unequivocally stand to protect press freedom” and conflates the issue of rights of the media to report freely and fairly with the national interest of “integrity and sovereignty”, the statement said. 

Criticising the PCI’s wording in the intervention application, the statement said it was, “deplorable, completely indefensible and strikes a severe blow against the struggle of journalists from Kashmir to be able to report freely on the effect of the abrogation of Article 370 (sic)”. The council’s move has come under severe criticism from the media fraternity. 

Also watch | Video by Fact-Finding Team Shows Unanimous Anger Against Centre in Kashmir

Pointing to the council’s own report released on October 9, 2017 after its visit to J&K, the statement says the PCI backing restrictions now is in sharp contrast. “The committee is really concerned about the stoppage of internet and mobile services in the State. In this age, no media can work without these supports. The policy of curbs on internet and mobile services has to be reviewed urgently,” the council’s report from 2017 had said.

The Chairman of the Press Council of India, former Justice Chandramauli Kumar Prasad. Photo: PTI

To highlight the importance of media freedom, the statement quoted from the current PCI chairman, Justice Chandramauli Kumar Prasad’s own speech on the occasion of the silver jubilee programme of the National Human Rights Commission of India held on September 5, 2018 at IIMC, Delhi.

“Media is the eyes and ears of any democratic society and its existence is vital to the smooth functioning of democracy. It guards the public interest and acts as voice of the voiceless,” he had reportedly said.

The statement concludes by urging the PCI to intervene in favour of Bhasin’s petition that demands an end to ban on communication in J&K and seeks directions to immediately relax all restrictions on mobile, internet and landline services. 

Also read: The Fate of Press Freedom in India Over the Years

“It appears that the Press Council of India is abrogating its Constitutional responsibility towards standing firmly and fearlessly for the freedom of the press and the right of the media to ‘act as the voice of the voiceless’. It flies in the face of the role of the Press Council of India as a statutory body to safeguard the rights of the media to fulfil its responsibility freely, without fear or favour. That is in the true national interest, irrespective of the interests of the government of the day,” it said. 

The National Alliance of Journalists and the Delhi Union of Journalists also released a statement strongly criticising the PCI chairman for his “unilateral move” to intervene in Bhasin’s petition. It condemned the chairman of “tomtoming the government’s interest” and “acting as its B team”.

They further called for “widest possible unity to ensure watch dogs do not become lap dogs of the government and other international interests with their own agenda of balkanisation of the country.”

The Press Association had issued a statement on Saturday, taking a serious view of the same. Members of the Council have alleged that they were not even informed about it and expressed shock and surprise. 

Also read | ‘This is Not the 1970s’: IAS Officer Quits in Anguish Over Kashmir ‘Emergency’

“The wording of this petition is so dangerous. Though the rules say that the chairman has to get the council’s endorsement for any decision he takes in between meetings, he did not even inform the council about the fact that the PCI is intervening in Anuradha Bhasin’s case,” one council member had told The Wire when asked about the PCI’s move to intervene. 

On the day Bhasin filed her writ petition in the apex court, The Editors Guild of India also issued a statement expressing concern over the lack of press freedom in Jammu and Kashmir. “The lockdown is almost total and draconian for the vibrant local media that are the first eyes and ears on the ground,” their statement said about the ban on communication and restrictions on mobility in the state. 

Senior journalist Krishna Prasad, also a former member of the council, called the PCI’s intervention “a shameful abdication of its responsibilities” while speaking to The Wire.

Following are the signatories to the statement.

Ajith Pillai, Journalist, Delhi
Akhileshwari Ramagoud
Ammu Joseph, Bangalore
Aniruddha Bahl
Anjali Mody, New Delhi
Anjuman Ara Begum, Guwahati
Aunohita Mojumdar, Editor, Himal Southasian
Avantika Mehta, New Delhi
C.G. Manjula, Bangalore
Chitra Ahanthem, Imphal
Deepanjana Pal
Dhanya Rajendran, Bangalore
Free Speech Collective
Geeta Seshu, Mumbai
Geetartha Pathak. Vice-President, Indian Journalists Union, Guwahati and former member,Press Council of India
Gita Aravamudan, Bangalore
Haima Deshpande, Thane
Iftikhar Gilani
Jayaditya Gupta
Kala Kanthan, Bangalore
Kamayani Mahabal, Mumbai
Laxmi Murthy, Bangalore
Linda Chhakchhuak, independent journalist, Shillong
M.D Riti, Bangalore
Mahesh Rajput, Journalist, Chandigarh
Malini Subramaniam
Manisha Pande
Meena Menon, Journalist, Mumbai
Melanie P Kumar, Bangalore
MJ Pandey, Journalist, Mumbai
Natasha Badhwar
Neeta Kolhatkar, Mumbai
Network of Women in Media, India (NWMI)
Niloufer Venkatraman
Padma Priya, Hyderabad
Padmaja Shaw, Hyderabad
Padmalatha Ravi, Bangalore
Paranjoy Guha Thakurta, former member, Press Council of India
Paroma Mukherjee
Poornima Joshi, Political Editor, Hindu Businessline
Prachi Pinglay, Bangalore
Prema Viswanathan, Bangalore
Preethi Nagaraj, Mysuru
Preeti Mehra, Journalist, Delhi
Priya Ramani, Bangalore
Pushpa Achanta, Bangalore
Radhika Ramaseshan, New Delhi
Rajashree Dasgupta, Kolkata
Rehmat Merchant, Bangalore
Rema Nagarajan
Revathi Siva Kumar, Bangalore
Revati Laul, New Delhi
Rituparna Chatterjee
Rohit Khanna, journalist
Rosamma Thomas, Pune
S.N. Sinha, former member, Press Council and Convenor of PCI report on Media of J&K, 2017
Teresa, Chennai
Sabarinath, Jaipur
Sabita Lahkar, independent journalist, Guwahati
Samar Halarnkar
Samhita Barooah, Meghalaya
Samrat Chakrabarti
Samrat Choudhury
Sandhya Ravishankar, Chennai
Sharda Ugra, Bangalore
Shobha SV, Independent media professional, Bangalore
Sohini C, Kolkata
Thingnam Anjulika Samom, Imphal
Tongam Rina, Itanagar
UNI Employees Union, Chandigarh
Valay Singh
Venu Arora, New Delhi
Vivek Mukherji